Side by side comparison
Sumatra and Ecuador
Fields follow the learning level door you picked on the home page. Empty catalog fields stay honest and empty.
Sensory Contrast at a Glance
Sweetness
Sumatra●●
Ecuador●●●●
Sparkle & Acidity
Sumatra●
Ecuador●●●
Body & Weight
Sumatra●●●●●
Ecuador●●●
Sensory Radar Overlay
- Sumatra
- Ecuador
| Metric | Sumatra | Ecuador |
|---|---|---|
| Summary | Heavy, low-acid, and earthy: cedar, cocoa, and forest-floor notes. Pick this only if you want a deep, savory cup rather than fruit. | Sweet and medium-bodied, with stone fruit and chocolate. Some heirloom lots (Sidra) add rose, honey, and apricot. |
| Tasting notes | cedar, dark cocoa, fresh pipe tobacco, damp forest, licorice | honey, apricot, rose, cocoa nib, cane sugar |
| Who grows it | Smallholders selling parchment to collectors and mills in Aceh and North Sumatra. | Family farms and small mills in Loja and the volcanic sierra. |
| Producers in detail | Lots are often blended at a mill that buys from many gardens. Traceable Gayo or Lintong bags may name a cooperative. The farm-life image is raking drying seed on concrete, not a Kenyan washing channel. Sorting by hand after hulling is still part of the cup quality. | Look for a finca name in Loja or a mill that separates Sidra from Typica. Producers here often process on-site (honey beds under plastic) rather than delivering to a giant cooperative. That mill-level control is why process varies bag to bag - always read washed vs honey. |
| Terroir | Tropical rainforest humidity, volcanic lakes (Toba) and highland basins (Gayo). Shade, clay, and wet harvest weather make slow, fully dry naturals risky - wet-hulling is terroir as method. Cedar and cocoa are the landscape in the cup. | Andes plus equator: intense sun, cool nights, and volcanoes (Cotopaxi is the postcard). Loja in the south is drier and known for sweetness; Pichincha nearer Quito is greener. Both are high enough for floral genetics to ripen slowly. |
| Process | Often wet-hulled (giling basah), typical of Sumatra. | Washed or honey - read the bag. |
| Process in detail | Cherry is pulped, briefly fermented, and dried only until the parchment is still damp. Hulling that wet parchment - giling basah - exposes a swollen seed that finishes drying on patios in humid air. The result is low acidity, heavy body, and cedar-herb notes. It is not a washed Ethiopia that went wrong; it is a different process chosen for a wet climate. | Loja and Pichincha mills wash for clarity or leave mucilage for honey lots that taste like apricot nectar. Sidra and Typica Mejorada are often honey-processed because the genetics already run floral; the mucilage amplifies that without turning the cup into a natural jam. Experimental anaerobic appears on competition menus, not on every grocery bag. |
| Brew tag | Filter or espresso | Filter |
| Bag cue | Look for Sumatra or Mandheling, earthy, low acid, dark cocoa. Gayo if Aceh is named. | Look for Ecuador, Loja or Sidra, honeyed stone fruit. |
| Cafe order | A Sumatra or Mandheling, the earthy low-acid one - French press or espresso, not a light pour-over. | An Ecuador, Loja or Sidra if you have it, light roast, black - honeyed stone fruit. |
| Milk | Black, Dairy, Oat | Black, Dairy |
| Species | arabica | arabica |
| Altitude (light) | Mid-highland - often 1,100–1,600m | High-grown valleys - about 1,200–2,000m |
| Altitude (detail) | Gayo highlands in Aceh and the Lintong / Mandheling areas around Lake Toba commonly sit 1,200–1,600m. That is respectable altitude, but wet-hulling and humidity mute the sparkle you would expect from the same elevation in Kenya. | Specialty lots from Loja, Vilcabamba, and the slopes around Quito commonly sit 1,200–2,000m. Equatorial sun plus altitude gives dense seeds and a stone-fruit sweetness that is less citrus than Kenya and less jasmine than washed Yirgacheffe. |
| Varieties | Tim Tim, Ateng, Onan Ganjang, Gayo selections (when labeled) | Sidra, Typica Mejorada, Typica (when labeled) |
| Harvest | Long, staggered harvests; many regions pick across much of the year, with peaks after rains. | Varies by slope; many highland lots are picked in the middle of the calendar year. |
| Brew rec | French press or espresso. A paper pour-over can taste too thin. Medium-dark roast is traditional; very light roast can taste vegetal. | Pour-over, light roast, 1:16. Honey Sidra can handle a slightly coarser grind so florals do not turn perfume-bitter. |